Silas T Nkoana

Competitors Outranking Me

Silas T Nkoana Avatar
Silas T Nkoana

When competitors are outranking you in Google, the solution is rarely a single “SEO trick” – it’s a structured, data‑driven strategy.

As a South African SEO & digital marketing consultant, I’ll walk through why competitors outrank you, what to do about it, and how to build a sustainable strategy around the target keyword “competitors outranking me”.

Why Are Competitors Outranking Me?

When you search for your primary keywords and keep thinking, “why are competitors outranking me?”, the answer usually sits in five areas:

  1. Technical SEO & Crawlability
    Search engines must be able to easily crawl and index your website. Issues like slow loading, blocked pages, incorrect redirects or poor mobile experience can hold you back. Google’s own documentation on Search Essentials (formerly Webmaster Guidelines) highlights technical accessibility and page experience as baseline requirements for visibility.

  2. Topical Relevance & Content Depth
    Google’s Helpful Content guidance explains that content should be written primarily to help users, not just to manipulate rankings. Competitors often win because they:

    • Cover topics more comprehensively
    • Answer more questions on the page
    • Use better structured headings and internal links
  3. E‑E‑A‑T (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, Trustworthiness)
    Google’s Search Quality Rater Guidelines emphasise E‑E‑A‑T as a framework used by quality raters to assess content quality. While it’s not a direct ranking factor, sites that demonstrate expertise and trust (real authors, transparent contact pages, clear business information) tend to perform better over time.

  4. Backlinks & Online Authority
    Authoritative, relevant backlinks are still among the strongest ranking signals, as described in Google’s own link best practices. Competitors outranking you often have:

    • More links
    • Better quality links
    • Mentions on credible industry sites and directories
  5. User Experience & Engagement
    Google emphasises page experience and Core Web Vitals – fast pages, stable layout and mobile-friendliness. When visitors quickly bounce, that’s often a sign your content or UX isn’t matching their intent.

Step 1: Diagnose Why Competitors Outrank You

Before making changes, perform a structured diagnosis so you’re not guessing.

1. Benchmark Your Technical SEO

Use tools such as:

  • Google Search Console, recommended in Google’s SEO starter guide, to check:
    • Coverage issues
    • Mobile usability
    • Core Web Vitals
  • PageSpeed Insights, described in Google’s performance documentation, to identify speed and performance issues compared with top competitors.

Look for:

  • Slow loading pages vs. competitor sites
  • Broken internal links or 404s
  • Non‑mobile‑friendly layouts
  • Incorrect indexing (noindex tags, canonical errors)

2. Analyse the Search Intent You’re Targeting

For terms like “competitors outranking me” and related queries, search the term in Google and assess the top results:

  • Are they how‑to guides, agency pages, or checklists?
  • Do competitors use case studies, statistics, or tools?
  • Which questions do they answer that you don’t?

Google’s guidance on understanding search intent points out that aligning your content with intent is central to performance.

3. Compare Content Depth & Structure

Take your main landing pages and compare them side‑by‑side with your top competitors’ pages:

  • Word count is less important than coverage.
  • Do they:
    • Use clearer headings (H1, H2, H3)?
    • Provide checklists, frameworks, or templates?
    • Explain concepts in more depth, with examples or visuals?

Google’s recommendations for structuring content emphasise clarity and organisation so search engines can understand context.

4. Evaluate Their Link Advantage

Use any reputable link analysis tool (Ahrefs, Semrush, Moz, etc.) to compare:

  • Number of referring domains
  • Authority of those domains
  • Types of sites linking (industry blogs, local directories, news sites, etc.)

Google’s guidance on building quality links makes it clear: links should be earned through useful content and legitimate promotion, not bought or manipulated.

Step 2: Build a Strategy Around “Competitors Outranking Me”

To outrank your competitors, you need a plan that combines technical, content and authority‑building efforts.

1. Fix Technical Issues That Block Performance

Guided by the issues surfaced in Search Console and PageSpeed Insights, prioritise:

  • Mobile‑first experience
    Follow Google’s mobile‑friendly recommendations to ensure:

    • Responsive design
    • Readable text without zooming
    • Tap‑friendly buttons
  • Core Web Vitals
    Improve Largest Contentful Paint (LCP), Cumulative Layout Shift (CLS) and Interaction to Next Paint (INP) as described in Core Web Vitals documentation.

  • Clean information architecture
    Google’s SEO starter guide recommends:

    • Simple, descriptive URL structure
    • Logical internal links between related pages
    • Clear navigation menus

2. Create a Dedicated “Competitors Outranking Me” Resource

If you want to rank for the target keyword “competitors outranking me”, build a page that directly addresses that problem in depth.

Use Google’s helpful content principles to shape it:

  • Focus on real user pain:
    Structure the page around core questions users type in when they feel outranked:

    • Why are competitors outranking me?
    • How do I find out what competitors are doing better?
    • What changes will actually move rankings?
  • Include actionable frameworks:
    Turn the content into a step‑by‑step system visitors can use, for example:

    1. Audit technical SEO
    2. Map search intent and keywords
    3. Benchmark content depth
    4. Analyse backlink profiles
    5. Implement & measure
  • Use clear on‑page SEO practices:
    As suggested in Google’s on‑page guidance:

    • Include the primary keyword naturally in:
    • Title tag
    • Meta description
    • H1
    • Early in the introduction
    • Use related terms like “why are competitors outranking me”, “improve rankings vs competitors” and “outrank competitors in Google” naturally throughout.

3. Demonstrate Expertise & Trust (E‑E‑A‑T)

To compete in SEO and digital marketing spaces, you need strong trust signals. According to Google’s E‑E‑A‑T guidance, strengthen:

  • About & author transparency
    • Show your real name and background.
    • Explain your professional experience in SEO and digital marketing.
  • Clear contact information
  • Case studies and testimonials
    • Without disclosing confidential data, describe how you helped previous clients improve visibility versus competitors, aligning with Google’s push for real‑world experience.

4. Build Authoritative, Relevant Backlinks

Use a sustainable link‑earning approach consistent with Google’s link spam and best‑practice policies:

  • Industry content collaborations
    • Guest insights on reputable marketing blogs
    • Co‑authored guides with non‑competing experts
  • Local & niche directories
    • Listings on credible business and professional directories relevant to South Africa or your region, in line with good practice from Google’s local SEO guidance.
  • Data‑driven content
    • Publish unique research, statistics or checklists that others naturally want to reference and link to.

Avoid paid link schemes, excessive reciprocal linking or private blog networks; these violate Google’s spam policies and can do long‑term damage.

Step 3: On‑Page Optimisation to Outrank Competitors

Once the content and strategy are clear, refine on‑page optimisation with Google’s own recommendations in mind.

1. Titles & Meta Descriptions

Based on the SEO starter guide, ensure:

  • Each page has a unique, descriptive title tag.
  • The target keyword “competitors outranking me” appears in the most relevant page title, in a natural way.
  • Meta descriptions are compelling summaries that encourage clicks, not keyword stuffing.

Example for a consulting page:

  • Title: “SEO & Digital Marketing Consultant – Fix Competitors Outranking Me”
  • Meta Description: “Frustrated that competitors are outranking you in Google? Get a technical, content and link‑focused SEO strategy from a specialist consultant to win back visibility and leads.”

2. Header Structure & Internal Links

Following Google’s guidance on organising content:

  • Use a single H1 per page reflecting the core topic.
  • Use H2/H3 headings to break down:
    • Reasons competitors outrank you
    • Step‑by‑step solutions
    • FAQ about rankings and competition
  • Internally link from related blog posts or services to your main “competitors outranking me” resource using descriptive anchor text, not generic “click here”.

Step 4: Measure Progress Against Competitors

To know if your efforts are working, regularly track and refine.

1. Use Google Search Console Data

As recommended in the SEO starter guide, monitor:

  • Queries where impressions are rising but click‑through rate is low
  • Average position for key terms like “competitors outranking me”
  • Pages gaining or losing visibility

Adjust page titles, meta descriptions and content based on this performance data.

2. Monitor Core Web Vitals Over Time

In line with Core Web Vitals recommendations:

  • Track changes after speed and UX optimisations.
  • Compare field data (real user metrics) with lab data from tools like Lighthouse.

3. Track Competitor Movements

Repeat your competitor analysis every few months:

  • Are new competitors entering the SERPs for your target keywords?
  • Have rivals significantly grown their backlink profiles?
  • Which types of content (video, long‑form guides, tools) start to dominate the first page?

Use these insights to decide whether to double down on existing content, expand into new formats or strengthen authority building.

When to Work with an SEO & Digital Marketing Consultant

If you’ve already tried basic optimisations and still find competitors outranking you, partnering with a consultant can help you:

  • Turn scattered efforts into a clear, prioritised roadmap
  • Align SEO, content, and conversion strategy with business goals
  • Avoid tactics that violate Google’s spam policies and risk penalties

An experienced consultant will base recommendations on the same principles outlined in Google’s own resources, such as the SEO starter guide, helpful content guidance, E‑E‑A‑T framework and link best practices, tailored to your specific market and competition.

If you’re consistently asking, “why are competitors outranking me in Google?”, the path forward is clear: diagnose with data, align your content with user intent, strengthen technical foundations, build genuine authority and measure progress relentlessly. Over time, this is how you move from being outranked to becoming the benchmark others are trying to surpass.

Other Posts